Bethany Notestine at the University of Cincinnati College of Law

Redeeming Justice

Bethany Notestine's Journey from Conviction to Law School

Before becoming a law student, Bethany Notestine (JD ‘25), dreamed of opening her own medical massage business. For most, starting a business from scratch can be an expensive and risky endeavor. But for Bethany, the biggest obstacle was her past.

“The Ohio Medical Board has a rule that says if you have a felony conviction you can't get your medical massage license,” Bethany said. “But there's an asterisk next to it that says, ‘unless the Board approves it.’ Most people would see that and feel defeated, but I saw that asterisk and went for it.” 

Emerging from a 7.5 year sentence the year prior, Bethany had walked out of federal prison to be embraced by her parents, then flown back to their place to live while she got back on her feet. But that would prove to be no easy task. Finding work with a record would be difficult.

Swept up into the justice system at the young age of 22 for a nonviolent drug trafficking offense, Bethany had opted for a plea deal out of fear of getting a potential life sentence if she went to trial. The consequence of her choice was a sentence marred by the reverberations of trauma, anger, and still more lingering questions.

While in prison, she sought solace in the quiet corners of the prison Law Library, where she devoted her time each morning to studying criminal cases, trying to make sense of how the justice system works and what went wrong in her own case. 

“What else was I going to do?” Bethany asked, “all I had (besides studying) was desperation.”

Bethany Notestine

After hours upon hours spent studying law materials, she began to make connections for her own case and understand how the legal system worked. At this point, she also realized she might have an actual knack for law. A calling even. 

Little did she know that studying these dense legal volumes would eventually come in handy when she decided to go after approval from the Ohio Medical Board for her medical massage license after getting released. But years after stepping into her prison cell, determined to carve out a life after incarceration, she hired an attorney, put in the work to present her case, and her license was approved unanimously. 

 

“That victory is what gave me confidence to achieve more," she said. "The Board was amazing. They let me prove myself and it propelled me into where I am now.”

While her medical massage and eyelash extension business ran successfully for five years, on days when business ownership was particularly hard, dreams of becoming a lawyer crept into her mind. Stopping her from dreaming too big were her own doubts about being able to get into law school, along with the trauma and the shame of incarceration. 

“I realized that I had more to offer – but for a long time I was scared,” she said. “I just prayed on it and leaned on my faith and decided that once I set my mind to something, there's no stopping me. That’s when I decided I was going back to school.”

It was that moment of vulnerability and courage that led her to apply to Cincinnati Law.  

“When I applied to Cincinnati Law, I was terrified. I had backup schools because with my background, I knew there would be schools that wouldn't take me,” she said. "It was so amazing when UC accepted me, I was thrilled. Then to get a scholarship… I am so happy to be here. UC means everything to me right now.” 

I realized that I had more to offer – but for a long time I was scared,” she said. “I just prayed on it and leaned on my faith and decided that once I set my mind to something, there's no stopping me. That’s when I decided I was going back to school.

Bethany Notestine

"It was so amazing when UC accepted me, I was thrilled. Then to get a scholarship… I am so happy to be here. UC means everything to me right now.”


- Bethany Notestine ‘25

Drawn especially to Cincinnati Law’s own Ohio Innocence Project (OIP), a program that helps defend victims of wrongful convictions, Bethany was accepted as a fellow to the program prior to matriculation at Cincinnati Law (an honor only a few applicants receive).

“Bethany’s application stood out because of her background...that made her uniquely qualified to understand our clients' situations,” said Jennifer Paschen Bergeron, Professor of Clinical Law at OIP.  “Her passion for and dedication to the cause was evident.” 

Bethany Notestine

“UC is the only Ohio law school that has an Innocence Project, and that was so important to me. It's great to be in an environment that is pro criminal defense,” Bethany said. “No one should be thrown away. When someone works to earn a second chance, they deserve to get it. When we take away a person’s ability to evolve, we take away their humanity.”  

This year, Bethany is working closely with Professor Christopher Bryant to reconstruct and examine the incident that has become known as the Battle of Bamber Bridge. This outbreak of racial violence against African American soldiers known as the Buffalo Soldiers during World War II has been largely ignored in both legal and historical literatures. Though it happened over 80 years ago, Bethany hopes that her research and anticipated publication of her findings may result in an official apology or even exoneration of some or all of the wrongly convicted Black soldiers. 

“Bethany has a passion for and appreciation of the opportunity to learn and join the legal profession,” said Professor Bryant. “She will be an outstanding attorney, and I feel blessed to be able play any role in her astounding progress.”

No one should be thrown away. When someone works to earn a second chance, they deserve to get it. When we take away a person’s ability to evolve, we take away their humanity.

Bethany Notestine

Bethany Notestine

Raised in Dayton, Ohio, by Catholic parents who adopted her after the loss of one of their children, Bethany said it has been this faith and her parents’ example of caring for others that helped her face even the darkest moments. Her faith has also made her a strong believer in redemption. “If our criminal justice system doesn’t include pathways to redemption, then it leaves people who have made mistakes to feel hopeless”, she said.

With this in mind, Bethany plans on using her lived experience with the justice system, coupled with her education and experience with OIP, to help change the system as a future criminal defense lawyer. 

“There are a lot of issues with [criminal] policy that, if we can change them, we can fix a lot of problems with wrongful convictions. Who better to fix the system than people who have experienced it on both sides?” she said. “I cannot lie to you, law school is stressful, it's hard, but I tell people all the time, I'm living the dream.” 

Today, she has her sights set on her future as a licensed attorney, and the opportunities she will have to not only give back—but make sense of how far she’s come.  

“I try not to ask, ‘Why did this happen to me? Why did I have to go through this?’ Because I know why I went through this. I went through this so I can help other people. I'm okay with this now,” she went on. “I’ve experienced so much pain…but I've been a fighter my whole life. I don't want to be a victim…I don't want people to look at me and feel sorry for me. I am so powerful, and I want to fight...I can't get the time back, I missed almost all of my twenties. But maybe I can help other people so that they don't go through what I went through.”


Want to learn more about our students and their journey to (and through) law school? Read more stories on the "Meet Our Students" page. See yourself at Cincinnati Law!   

Author: Bachmeyer Press

There's more to this story. Request information today.

Loading...


Get to Know Cincinnati Law

UC Law student at gradutaion

Class Profile for Incoming Class of 2026

  • 128 enrolled
  • Median LSAT: 158
  • Median UGPA: 3.80
  • 67 Colleges & Universities represented
  • 25% identify as minority
  • 19% identify as LGBTQIA+
law school orientation

Affordability

  • 95% of the student body received renewable scholarships with amounts ranging from $2,500 to full tuition
  • In-State tuition: $24,010
  • Non-Resident tuition: $29,010
  • Cincinnati Law boasts one of the lowest debt-upon-graduation rates in the nation
oip students

Experiences

  • 7 Clinics
  • 6 Centers
  • 4 Legal Journals
  • 40+ student organizations
  • 8:1 student-to-faculty ratio